Supreme
Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett authored the majority opinion ruling in
favor of a Mississippi law allowing mail-in ballots to be counted even if
they are received after Election Day.
The
court was split 5-4 on the ruling with the turncoat Barrett, appointed
by President Donald Trump, joined by Chief Justice John (“No
Balls”) Roberts, as well as the usual Marxists in Black, justices Sonia
Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson. The sane minority, including
justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Samuel Alito were almost
certainly shocked and appalled by the outcome.
Barrett’s
opinion ignored the fact that federal law seems clear, in that all ballots must
be received by Election Day to be counted. Incredibly, Barett’s opinion
apparently acknowledged that federal law does mandate that Election Day is the
deadline for voters to make a choice as to their preferred candidate, but
that there is no standard for when ballots must be received to be
considered valid. When the polls close? One week later? One month? A year?
Meh. Que sera sera. It’s all good.
(This
is like a sporting event where you have 90 minutes to determine a winner, yet
goals continue to count for some time after. Oh wait, that’s soccer.)
In
his dissent, Justice Samuel Alito stated that Justice Amy Comey Barrett's
opinion was clearly inconsistent with the plain text of the laws and of historical
practice and precedents, adding that it “risks further undermining Americans'
confidence in election integrity." You think?
But
SCOTUS rulings are no longer about interpreting the Constitution, legal
precedent—or right or wrong—but about advancing a political agenda. This ruling
is doubly damaging, as it calls into question the legitimacy of the Supreme
Court itself, a disaster for the republic, but also further degrades any
possible confidence in election integrity and results, the death knell for a
“democracy.” Given the existing political climate and pervasive doubt about the
validity of our elections, this ruling is an existential threat to the United
States as it approaches its 250th birthday celebration.
(Moreover,
it does nothing good for the reputation of “women in black.” Historical
ignorance, flawed logic, and emotional, agenda-driven decisions do not reflect
well on those who make them.)
But
wait, there’s hope! In late-arriving news, it turns out President Trump has
not, in fact, nominated Barrett for the Court. He subsequently decided on Ted Cruz!
Barrett’s ruling will be expunged and America has been saved!